Posted by Kevin on July 1, 2020 under Bankruptcy Blog | 
The massive $2.2 trillion coronavirus relief law includes some legal relief for both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 consumer debtors.
$1,200 Relief Checks Excluded as Income for the Means Test
To qualify to file a consumer Chapter 7 case, you have to pass the “means test.” Part of that test is a rather complicated calculation of your “current monthly income.” That’s essentially the average of the last 6 full calendar months of income from virtually all sources. A single large payment—such as a $1,200 coronavirus relief payment—could pump up your “current monthly income” and make you fail the “means test.” Then you could be forced to file a multi-year Chapter 13 case instead of a 3-4 month Chapter 7 one.
The new CARES law solves that problem neatly. It simply excludes any coronavirus relief money from the definition of “current monthly income.” To be precise, the following is excluded:
Payments made under Federal law relating to the national emergency declared by the President under the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.) with respect to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID–19).
Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES”), Section 1113(b)(1)(A).
What Payments Are Included?
This statutory language is broad. It doesn’t refer only to the one-time $1,200 (or so) relief payment. It’s clearly broad enough that it could include other “Payments made under Federal law” related to the coronavirus national emergency. That is, other such payments may be excluded from “current monthly income” for purposes of the means test.
For example, CARES provides unemployment benefits of $600 per week extra beyond the usual state-calculated weekly amounts. These $600 weekly extra benefits sure sound like they’re “Payments made under Federal law” related to [this] national emergency.” Since these $600 payments can last up to 39 weeks, they can amount to way more money than the one-time $1,200 payments. So if these $600 payments are also excluded in applying the means test, that would be quite significant.
But this is a new law, and there certainly is no case law that has developed on this issue. Moreover, any “law” on this issue may well be applied somewhat differently in different parts of the country. Contact your local bankruptcy lawyer for current information as it applies to you.
$1,200 Relief Checks Also Excluded in Confirmation of Chapter 13 Plan
Chapter 13 generally requires you to pay all of your “projected disposable income” into your 3-to-5-year payment plan. This monthly amount goes through the Chapter 13 trustee to your creditors under the terms of your plan. Then at the end of the plan you are usually debt-free (except sometimes for certain agreed long-term debts).
Your “projected disposable income” is based on virtually all your income, minus certain legally allowed expenses. The income side of this is your “current monthly income” as discussed above—based on your last 6 months of income. If that income would include a one-time coronavirus relief payment, it would greatly increase your “disposable income” and thus your required Chapter 13 plan payment.
The new CARES law solves that problem in a way similar to the above section about the Chapter 7 means test. Using the exact same language, it excludes any coronavirus relief money from the Chapter 13 definition of “current monthly income.” To again be precise, the following is excluded:
… payments made under Federal law relating to the national emergency declared by the President under the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.) with respect to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID–19).
CARES, Section 1113(b)(1)(B).
As in the section above on Chapter 7, it’s not yet clear what federal payments are excludable. Besides the $600 weekly unemployment payments mentioned above, there may be other future coronavirus stimulus payments approved by Congress. Again, talk with your bankruptcy lawyer to get current information and advice.
Changes to Ongoing Chapter 13 Plans
During the course of a Chapter 13 you can change, or “modify” your approved payment plan under certain circumstances. CARES added a new circumstance: if you are “experiencing or [have] experienced a material financial hardship due, directly or indirectly, to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID–19) pandemic.” CARES, Section 1113(b)(1)(C).
The bankruptcy judge still has to approve the modified plan, after the usual notice to creditors and opportunity for objection. The modified plan must comply with the usual requirements. (“Sections 1322(a), 1322(b), 1323(c), and the requirements of section 1325(a) shall apply to any [such plan] modification… .” CARES, Section 1113(b)(1)(C).)
It’s unclear what this all adds to the plan modification rights you already have, except for one huge change. The law has been clear for a long time: Chapter 13 plans cannot last longer than 5 years. CARES extended this to a new maximum of 7 years for applicable modified plans.
Although you’d think you would want to finish your plan as fast as possible, longer plans often allow you to reduce your monthly plan payments. It can give you more opportunities to preserve certain assets or collateral—keep a vehicle, save a home. Given the financial challenges so many of us are facing, this greater flexibility can make the difference between completing your case case successfully or not.
Important: Applicability to Cases
First, the Chapter 7 means test change and the Chapter 13 plan confirmation change “apply to any case commenced before, on, or after the date of enactment of this Act.” CARES, Section 1113(b)(1)(D(i). But those changes have a sunset provision—they are deleted from the Bankruptcy Code effective “on the date that is 1 year after the date of enactment.” CARES, Section 1113(b)(2).
CARES was enacted on March 27, 2020. That means that these two changes apply to all cases filed any time before that date but only through March 26, 2021. Be careful about this deadline.
Second, the Chapter 13 plan modification change applies “apply to any case for which a plan has been confirmed… before the date of enactment of this Act.” CARES, Section 1113(b)(1)(D(ii). But, same as above, this change has a sunset provision—it is deleted from the Bankruptcy Code effective “on the date that is 1 year after the date of enactment.” CARES, Section 1113(b)(2).
So this change applies to Chapter 13 cases which had a confirmed plan before March 27, 2020, and then successfully modified its plans by March 26, 2021. Be careful about this deadline as well.
Notice that by this language this change does not apply to cases either not filed, or already filed but not yet confirmed, as of March 27, 2020. This means that people in these situations appear unable to take advantage of the 7-year provision.
Bottom line all these changes to the Bankruptcy Code are temporary, currently lasting only this one year. Then they will be deleted and the Bankruptcy Code will revert to its prior language.
Posted by Kevin on January 28, 2019 under Bankruptcy Blog |
In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the debtor makes no payments and gets to keep her exempt assets. For a vast majority of debtors, this means they get to keep all their assets. The average Chapter 7 is completed in about 4 months
Creditors did not like this and lobbied for 20 years for a major overhaul of consumer bankruptcies. The result was the 2005 revisions to the Bankruptcy Code which was supposed to force more debtors to file under Chapter 13 where monthly payments of 36-60 months are required. This was accomplished by imposition of the “means test” -supposedly an objective way to decide who qualifies to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
The “Objective” Rule
If you make under the median income for your State based on household size, you pretty much qualify for Chapter 7. If your income is above median, you must deduct from your income a combination of actual expenses and average local, State and national expenses to come up with your monthly disposable income.
-
- If your monthly disposable income is less than $128.33, then you pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7.
- If your monthly disposable income is between $128.33 and $214.17, then you go a step further: multiply that “disposable income” amount by 60, and compare that to the total amount of your regular (not “priority”) unsecured debts. If that multiplied disposable income” amount is less than 25% of those debts, then you still pass the “means test” and qualify for Chapter 7.
- If EITHER you can pay 25% or more of those debts, OR if your monthly disposable income is $214.17 or more, then you do NOT pass the means test. With rare exceptions, that means that you cannot file under Chapter 7.
There is not much difference between $128.33 per month and $214.17 per month- about $86 per month. Just enough for dinner for 2 at a decent restaurant. But at the low end, you can get through bankruptcy in 4 months and make no payments. At the high end, you make monthly payments for 3 to 5 years.
So where do these hugely important numbers come from? The Bankruptcy Code actually refers to those numbers multiplied by 60—$7,700 and $12,850. When the law was originally passed in 2005 these amounts were actually $6,000 and $10,000 (therefore, $100 and $167 monthly), but they have been adjusted for inflation since then.
So where did those original $6,000 and $10,000 amounts come from?
They are basically arbitrary. Maybe creditor lobbyists or congressional staffers floated the idea. Who knows? But, somewhere in the process Congress decided that it needed to use certain numbers, and those are the ones that made it into the legislation. It’s the law, regardless that there doesn’t seem to be any real principled reason for using those amounts.
The Bottom Line
Sensible or not, if your income is under the published median income amount, then you pass the “means test” and can proceed under Chapter 7. But if you are over the median income amount, then the amount of your monthly disposable income largely determines whether you are able to file a Chapter 7 case.
Posted by on January 13, 2019 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Because of how precisely the amount of your “income” is calculated, filing bankruptcy just a day or two later can make all the difference.
Passing the “Means Test”
“Income” for purposes of the Means Test includes income from any source except monies received under the Social Security Act. It includes income from irregular sources such as child and spousal support payments, insurance settlements, cash gifts from relatives, and unemployment benefits. Also, the Means Test is time-sensitive in that it is based on the amount of money received during precisely the 6 FULL CALENDAR months before the date of filing. This means that your “income” can shift by waiting just a month or two.
Why is the Definition of “Income” for the “Means Test” So Rigid?
One of the much-touted goals of the last major amendments to the bankruptcy law in 2005 was to prevent people from filing Chapter 7 who were considered not deserving. The most direct means to that end was to try to force more people to pay a portion of their debts through Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” instead of writing them off Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy.”
The primary tool intended to accomplish this is the “means test,” Its rationale was that instead of allowing judges to decide who was abusing the bankruptcy system, a rigid financial test would determine who had the “means” to pay a meaningful amount to their creditors in a Chapter 13 case, and therefore could not file a Chapter 7 case.
The Unintended Consequences of the “Means Test”
If your income is at or under the applicable median income, then you generally get to file a Chapter 7 case. If your income is higher than the median amount, you may still be able to file a Chapter 7 case but you have to jump through a whole bunch of extra hoops to do so. Having income below the median income amount makes qualifying for Chapter 7 much simpler and less risky.
Filing your case a day earlier or later can matter because of the means test’s fixation on the six prior full calendar months.
So if you receive some irregular chunk of money, it can push you over your applicable median income amount, and jeopardize your ability to qualify for Chapter 7.
An Example
It does not necessarily take a large irregular chunk of money to make this difference, especially if your income without that is already close to the median income amount. An income tax refund, some catch-up child support payments, or an insurance settlement or reimbursement could be enough.
Imagine having received $3,000 catch up support payment on July 15 of last year. Your only other income is from your job, where you make a $42,000 salary, or $3,500 gross per month. Let’s assume the median annual income for your state and family size is $45,000.
So imagine that now in January, 2019, your Chapter 7 bankruptcy paperwork is ready to file, and you would like to get it filed to get protection from your aggressive creditors. If your case is filed on or before January 31, then the last six full calendar month period would be July 1, 2018 through December 31, 2018. That period includes that $3,000 extra money you received in mid-July. Your work income of 6 times $3,500 equals $21,000, plus the extra $3,000 received, totals $24,000 received during that 6-month period. Multiply that by 2 for the annual amount—$48,000. Since that’s larger than the applicable $45,000 median income, you would have failed the income portion of the “means test.”
But if you just wait to file until February 1, then the applicable 6-month period jumps forward by one full month to the period from August 1 of last year through January 31 of this year. That new period no longer includes the $3,000 you received in mid-July. So your income during the 6-month period is $21,000, multiplied by 2 is $42,000. This results in your income being less than the $45,000 median income amount. You’ve now passed the “means test,” and qualified for Chapter 7.
Posted by Kevin on December 10, 2018 under Bankruptcy Blog |
The timing of your bankruptcy filing can determine whether you qualify for quick Chapter 7 vs. paying into a Chapter 13 plan for 3-5 years.
The means test requires people who have the “means” to do so, to pay a meaningful amount on their debts. If you don’t pass the means test you’re effectively stuck with filing a Chapter 13 case.
Be aware that a majority of people who need a Chapter 7 case successfully pass the means test. The most direct way to do so is if your income is no larger than the published “median income” amounts designated for your state and family size. What’s crucial here is the highly unusual way the means test defines income. This can create potential timing advantages and disadvantages.
The Means Test Definition of Income
When considering income for purposes of the means test, don’t think of income as you normally would. Instead:
1) Consider almost all sources of money coming to you in just about any form as income. Included, for example, are disability, workers’ compensation, and unemployment benefits; pension, retirement, and annuity payments received; regular contributions for household expenses by anybody, including a spouse or ex-spouse; rental or other business income; interest, dividends, and royalties. Pretty much the only money excluded are those received under the Social Security Act, including retirement, disability (SSDI), Supplemental Security Income (SSI), and Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF).
2) The period of time that counts for the means test is exactly the 6 full calendar months before your bankruptcy filing date. Included as income is ONLY the money you receive during those specific months. This excludes money received before that 6-month block of time. It also excludes any money received during the calendar month that you file your Chapter 7 case. To clarify this, if you filed a Chapter 7 case this December 15th, your income for the means test would include all money received from exactly June 1 through November 30 of this year.
The Effect of this Unusual Definition of Income
This timing rule means that your means test income can change depending on what month you file your case.
So if you receive an unusual amount of money anytime in December, it doesn’t count if you file a Chapter 7 case by December 31. Think year end bonus. Remember, if you file bankruptcy in December, only money received June through November gets counted.
So let’s say you got an extra $1,500 as a bonus in December. If you file in December that extra doesn’t count. But if you wait until January to file, December money is counted because the pertinent 6-month period is now July 1 through December 31. That extra $1,500 gets doubled, increasing your annual income by $3,000. That could push you above the designated “median income” for your state and family size. Then, you may not qualify for Chapter 7.
Conclusion
It is a fact that most people wait way too long before their initial consultation with a bankruptcy lawyer. Our advice is to consult early so you can know your options and possibly formulate a strategy which can save you money over the long haul.
Posted by Kevin on June 7, 2018 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Eligibility depends on 1) the kind of debtor, 2) the kinds and amounts of debts, 3) the amount of income and 4) of expenses.
1) The Kind of Debtor
If you are a human person, you may be eligible for either a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” or a Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” case. You and your spouse may also be eligible to file one or the other of these together in a joint case.
However, if you are the owner or part-owner of a business partnership, corporation, limited liability company or other similar business entity, that business entity could not file its own Chapter 13 case. But it could file under Chapter 7.
2) The Kinds and Amounts of Debts
If your debts are “primarily consumer debts” (more than 50% by dollar amount), then to be able to file a successful Chapter 7 case you have to pass the “means test.” That’s a test related to your income and expenses (discussed more below.) If 50% or more of your debts are not consumer debts, than you can skip the “means test.”
Chapter 7 does not limit the amount of debt you can have to be eligible to file a case. However, you cannot file a Chapter 13 case if your debts exceed the maximums of $394,725 in unsecured debts and $1,184,200 in secured debts (or if you do file a case it will very likely be “dismissed” (thrown out)).
3) Amount of Income
You can quickly and easily satisfy the “means test” and be eligible for a Chapter 7 case if your income is no more than the regularly adjusted and published “median income” for your family size and state.
To be eligible for Chapter 13 you must have “regular income.” That is defined not very helpfully as income “sufficiently stable and regular” to enable you to “make payments under a [Chapter 13] plan.”
Also for Chapter 13, if your income is less than the “median income” for your family size and state of residence, then the plan generally must last a minimum of three years (but in many situations it can last longer, especially if you need it to, but for no longer than five years). If your income is at or above the applicable “median income” amount, the plan must almost always last five years.
4) The Amount of Expenses
In Chapter 7, if your income is NOT less than “median income” for your family size and state of residence, then you may still pass the “means test” and be eligible for filing a Chapter 7 case IF, after accounting for all your allowed expenses, you don’t have enough money left over to pay a meaningful amount to your creditors.
In Chapter 13, a similar accounting of your allowed expenses determines the amount of your “disposable income,” the amount you must pay into your plan each month.
Summary
Once you recognize that you need relief from your creditors, choosing between Chapter 7 and 13 is often not difficult. But because there are many, many differences between them, the choice can sometimes turn into a delicate balancing act between the advantages and disadvantages of those two options. That’s why when you have your initial meeting with your bankruptcy attorney, it’s smart to be aware of and communicate your goals, but also be open-minded about how best to accomplish them.
Posted by Kevin on March 28, 2018 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Whether to file under Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 depends largely on your business assets, taxes, and other nondischargeable debts.
You have closed down your business and are considering bankruptcy. What are your options?
If you operated as a sole proprietor (DBA), then all the debts of the business are your personal debts. If you operated as a corporation or LLC, then the business was a separate entity. So, the business entity is liable for its debts, then, absent fraud, you are liable only for those debts which you personally guaranteed. In addition, you personally may be liable to taxing authorities for certain taxes.
Then, you have to consider remaining assets of the business. If a DBA, then you own the assets which become part of your bankruptcy estate upon filing. If it a corporation or LLC, then the entity owns the assets. But if you are the 100% owner of the business, then the stock or other ownership interest is an asset of the bankruptcy estate. So, the trustee can get to the assets through your ownership interest.
Your options would be to file under Chapter 7 or Chapter 13. A Chapter 7 is generally over in 4-5 months and requires no payments. A Chapter 13 lasts from 36-60 months and requires payments each month. It would be understandable if you preferred to file under Chapter 7.
Likely Can File Under Chapter 7 Under the “Means Test”
The “means test” determines whether, with your income and expenses, you can file a Chapter 7 case. The “means test” will still not likely be a problem if you closed down your business recently. That’s because the period of income that counts for the “means test” is the six full calendar months before your bankruptcy case is filed. An about-to-fail business usually isn’t generating much income. So, there is a very good chance that your income for “means test” purposes is less than the published median income amount for your family size, in your state. If your prior 6-month income is less than the median amount, by that fact alone you’ve passed the means test and qualified for Chapter 7.
Three Factors about Filing Chapter 7 vs. 13—Business Assets, Taxes, and Other Non-Discharged Debt
The following three factors seem to come up all the time when deciding between filing Chapter 7 or 13:
1. Business assets: A Chapter 7 case is either “asset” or “no asset.” In a “no asset” case, the Chapter 7 trustee decides—usually quite quickly—that all of your assets are exempt (protected by exemptions) and so cannot be taken from you to pay creditors.
If you had a recently closed business, there more likely are assets that are not exempt and are worth the trustee’s effort to collect and liquidate. If you have such collectable business assets, discuss with your attorney where the money from the proceeds of the Chapter 7 trustee’s sale of those assets would likely go, and whether that result is in your best interest compared to what would happen to those assets in a Chapter 13 case.
2. Taxes: It seems like every person who has recently closed a business and is considering bankruptcy has tax debts. Although some taxes can be discharged in a Chapter 7 case, many cannot. Especially in situations in which a lot of taxes would not be discharged, Chapter 13 is often a better way to deal with them.
3. Other nondischargeable debts: Bankruptcies involving former businesses get more than the usual amount of challenges by creditors. These challenges are usually by creditors trying to avoid the discharge (legal write-off) of its debts based on allegations of fraud or misrepresentation. The business owner may be accused of acting in some fraudulent fashion against a former business partner, his or her business landlord, or some other major creditor. These kinds of disputes can greatly complicate a bankruptcy case, regardless whether occurring under Chapter 7 or 13. But in some situations Chapter 13 could give you certain legal and tactical advantages over Chapter 7.
Posted by Kevin on February 18, 2018 under Bankruptcy Blog |
If your income is lower than the median income for your household size within your State, there is a “no presumption of abuse” and you can, almost always, file under Chapter 7. If, however, your income is higher than “median income,” you may still file a Chapter 7 case by going through the expenses step of the Means Test.
The concept behind the Means Test is pretty straightforward: people who have the means to pay a meaningful amount to their creditors over a reasonable period of time should be required to do so. That means they must file under Chapter 13 where payments are made to creditors over a 3-5 year period.
But putting that concept into law resulted in an amazingly complicated set of rules.
One of the complications is that the allowed expenses include some based on your stated actual expense amounts, while others are based on standard amounts. The standard amounts are based on Internal Revenue Service tables of expenses, but some of those standards are national and some vary by state. There are even some expenses which are partly standard and partly actual (certain components of transportation expenses).
Disposable Income
If after subtracting all the allowed expenses from your “income” you have some money left over, whether you can be in Chapter 7 depends on the amount of that money and how that compares to the amount of your debts:
- If the amount left over—the “monthly disposable income”—is no more than $128.33, then you still pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7.
- If your “monthly disposable income” is between $128.33 and $214.17, then apply the following formula: multiply that amount by 60, and compare that to the total amount of your regular (not “priority”) unsecured debts. If the multiplied total is less than 25% of those debts, then you still pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7.
- If after applying the above formula you can pay 25% or more of those debts, OR if your “monthly disposable income” is more than $214.17, then you do NOT pass the means test, UNLESS you can show “special circumstances”.
THAT’s Complicated!
If you don’t pass the means test you, will likely end up in a 3-to-5-year Chapter 13 case. Not only will that mean you cannot discharge your debts until the end of the 3-5 year period, but you may well also end up paying thousands, or even tens of thousands, more dollars to your creditors. It’s definitely worth going through the effort to find a competent bankruptcy attorney to help you, whenever possible, find a way to pass the means test.
Posted by Kevin on November 3, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
In Chapter 7, debtors make no payments to their creditors but a Chapter 7 trustee can sell all non-exempt property and pay unsecured creditors. The process is over in 4 months or so, and the debtor obtains a discharge of most of her debts. In Chapter 13, however, debtors get to keep even their non-exempt property but must make monthly payments to the Chapter 13 trustee for a period of 36 to 60 months before they can get a discharge of most of their debts.
So, we are assuming that you are having trouble paying your bills. You are contemplating bankruptcy. Why would you choose to make payments for 3 to 5 years to get a discharge when you can pay nothing and get a discharge in 4 months. Well, there are a number of reasons why prospective debtors pick Chapter 13. In 2005, Bankruptcy Code was amended by a law referred to as BAPCPA. BAPCPA adopted what is called the Means Test to determine if you could file under Chapter 7. If your income based on family size exceeds the median for your State, you must pass the Means Test to file under Chapter 7. The Means Test is based on IRS tests to determine how much a taxpayer can pay in back taxes. So, if you are above median income and you fail the Means Test, you cannot file Chapter 7, and are be required to file under Chapter 13 if you otherwise qualify.
But, there are other reasons to file under Chapter 13 even if you pass the Means Test. Say you own a home with significant equity. In a Chapter 7, the trustee can sell your home and pay off your creditors. In a Chapter 13, if you make all payments under a Plan confirmed by the Court, you can keep your home. In addition, let’s say that you own a home but are in arrears on the mortgage. In Chapter 13, you can pay off the arrears over the term of the Plan. That could be up to 60 months.
Finally, say your house was worth $400,000 when you bought it, but after the mortgage crisis, it is only worth $250,000. You owe $270,000 on a first mortgage and $50,000 on a second mortgage. In this case, the collateral covers most of the first mortgage, but the second mortgage is completely unsecured. In other words, if there was a foreclosure, the first mortgage holder would be paid a good amount of what it is owed, but the second mortgage holder would get nothing. In Chapter 13 in our example, you can “strip off” that second mortgage and treat it as unsecured debt since there is no collateral to attach to that mortgage. So, instead of making monthly payments of, say, $300 per month on the second, that creditor gets only a pro rata share of what is paid to the unsecured creditors. If your plan payment is, say, $100 per month, then the second mortgage holder gets to share that $100 with the other unsecured creditors instead of getting $300 per month. A substantial savings. If you make all the payments, the second mortgage holder is required to release the mortgage lien of record.
In some cases, you are forced into Chapter 13, but that does not mean that Chapter 13 cannot provide some real benefits, especially to homeowners. If you think Chapter 13 can help your situation, you should speak with an experienced bankruptcy attorney. Chapter 13 is not a DIY project.
Posted by Kevin on July 25, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
How can you tell if your Chapter 7 case will be straightforward? Avoid 4 problems.
Most Chapter 7 cases ARE straightforward. Your bankruptcy documents are prepared by your attorney and filed at court, about a month later you go to a simple 10-minute hearing with your attorney, and then two more months later your debts are discharged—written off. There’s a lot going on behind the scenes but that’s usually the gist of it.
But some cases ARE more complicated. How can you tell if your case will likely be straightforward or instead will be one of the relatively few more complicated ones?
The four main problem areas are: 1) income, 2) assets, 3) creditor challenges, and 4) trustee challenges.
1) Income
Most people filing under Chapter 7 have less income than the median income amounts for their state and family size. That enables them to easily pass the “means test.” But if instead you made or received too much money during the precise period of 6 full calendar months before your case is filed, you can be disqualified from Chapter 7. Or you may have to jump through some more complicated steps to establish that you are not “abusing” Chapter 7. Otherwise you could be forced into a 3-to-5 year Chapter 13 case or your case could be dismissed—thrown out of court. These results can sometimes be avoided with careful timing of your case, or even by making change to your income before filing.
2) Assets
Under Chapter 7 if you have an asset which is not protected (“exempt”), the Chapter 7 trustee can take and sell that asset, and pay the proceeds to the creditors. You may be willing to surrender a particular asset you don’t need in return for the discharge of your debts. That could especially be true if the trustee would use those proceeds in part to pay a debt that you want and need to be paid anyway, such as back payments of child support or income taxes. Or you may want to pay off the trustee through monthly payments in return for the privilege of keeping that asset. In these “asset” scenarios, there are complications not present in the more common “no asset” cases.
3) Creditor Challenges to the Dischargeability of a Debt
Creditors have a limited right to raise objections to the discharge of their individual debts. This is limited to grounds such as fraud, misrepresentation, theft, intentional injury to person or property, and similar bad acts. With most of these, the creditor must raise such objections to dischargeability within about three months of the filing of your Chapter 7 case—precisely 60 days after your “Meeting of Creditors.” Once that deadline passes your creditors can no longer complain, assuming that they received notice of your bankruptcy case.
4) Trustee Challenges to the Discharge of All Debts
In rare circumstances, such as if you do not disclose all your assets or fail to answer other questions accurately, either in writing or orally at the trustee’s Meeting of Creditors, or if you don’t cooperate with the trustee’s review of your financial circumstances, you could possibly lose the right to discharge any of your debts. The bankruptcy system largely relies on the honesty and accuracy of debtors. So it is quite harsh towards those who abuse the system through deceit.
No Surprises
Most of the time, Chapter 7s are straightforward. The most important thing you can do towards that end is to be completely honest and thorough with your attorney during your meetings and through the information and documents you provide. That way you will find out if there are likely to be any complications, and if so whether they can be avoided, or, if not, how they can be addressed in the best way possible.
Posted by Kevin on May 30, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Most people considering Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” have low enough income to qualify. Find out if you do.
The “Means” Part of the “Means Test”
When Congress passed the last major set of changes to the bankruptcy laws in 2005, it explicitly said that wanted to make it harder for some people to file Chapter 7. The idea was that those who have the means to pay a significant amount of their debts should do so. Specifically, those who can pay a certain amount to their creditors within a three-to-five-year Chapter 13 payment plan ought to do so, instead of just being able to write off all their debts in a Chapter 7 case.
How the Law Determines Whether You Have Too Much “Means”
The “means test” measures people’s “means” in a peculiar, two-part way, the first part based on income, the second part based on expenses.
The income part is relatively straightforward; the expense part involves an amazingly complicated formula of allowed expenses.
The good news is that if your income is low enough on the income part of the “means test,” then you’re done: you’ve passed the test and can skip the rest of the test. The other good news is that most people who want to file a Chapter 7 case DO have low enough income so that they do pass the “means test” based simply on their income.
Is YOUR Income Low Enough to Pass the “Means Test”?
Your income is low enough if it is no higher than the published “median income” for a household of your size in your state. You can look at your “median income” on https://www.justice.gov/ust/means-testing.
A Peculiar Definition of “Income”
Here’s what you need to know to compare your “income” (as used for this purpose) to the “median income” applicable to your state and family size:
1. Determine the exact amount of “income” you received during the SIX FULL calendar months before your bankruptcy case is filed. It’s easiest to explain this by example: if your Chapter 7 case is to be filed in July, 2017 , count every dollar you received during the six-month period from January 1,, 2017 through June 30, 2017. After coming up with that six-month total, divide it by six for the monthly average.
2.When adding up your “income” include all that you’ve acquired from all sources during that six-month period of time, including unconventional sources like child and spousal support payments, insurance settlements, unemployment benefits, and bonuses. But EXCLUDE any income from Social Security.
3. Multiply your six-month average monthly income by 12 for your annual income. Compare that amount to the published median income for your state and your size of family in the link provided above. (Make sure you’re using the current table.)
Conclusion
If your “income”—calculated in the precise way detailed here—is no more than the median income for your state and family size, then you have passed the “means test” and can file a Chapter 7 case.
But if your income is higher than that, you may still be able to pass the “means test” and file a Chapter 7 case. That is a little more complicated, however.
Posted by on May 28, 2016 under Bankruptcy Blog |
From the mid-1990’s to 2005, the creditor lobby worked hard to change the Bankruptcy Code. In their eyes, too many people, who could afford to pay part of their debts, were filing under Chapter 7 and walking away scot free. They wanted people to be forced into Chapter 13, where you have to make monthly payments to a Trustee for 36-60 months if the prospective debtor had the means to pay. Finally, in 2005, Congress changed the law which is called “Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection ” Act (BAPCPA). 11 years later, there is still confusion among the public about whether you can still file for Chapter 7, or you must file under Chapter 13. To qualify for Chapter 7, you have to pass the Means Test, the bankruptcy court version of what the IRS uses to determine what you can pay on back taxes. The Means Test is not straightforward, and some issues concerning its application are not clear even after a decade of BAPCPA. However, the bottom line is that you can still file under Chapter 7.
1. Bad Publicity
The creditor lobby, the media and sometimes even the bankruptcy system have all had a hand in making many people think that qualifying for “straight bankruptcy” is hard. While it is true that for the first couple of years, Chapter 13 filings were up, after debtor attorneys started to understand the new system, the vast majority of filings in New Jersey are still under Chapter 7.
2. A Confusing Statute
Upfront, BAPCPA is loaded with abuse prevention but I don’t see much consumer protection. The law is poorly written, confusing and sometimes one section contradicts another section. Moreover, because of these statutory contradictions and ambiguities, Courts, all the way up to the Supreme Court, have been scratching their heads trying to make sense of it. If the judges are having trouble with the complexities of the new law, then it is no surprise that ordinary people are confused.
3. Most Can “Skip” the “Means Test”
Parts of the “means test”–the major mechanism now for qualifying under Chapter 7—are mind-numbingly confusing, but many people can avoid all that simply by virtue of their income. Without getting into the calculations here, basically if your “income” (as specially defined for this purpose) before filing was no more than the published median income amount for your state and size of family, then you qualify for Chapter 7 without needing to go through any more of the “means test.”
Also, certain kinds of folks can skip the “means test” no matter the amount of their income, specifically present or recent business owners who have more business debt than consumer debt.
4. Passing the Means Test turned out to be easier than we thought
Even if you are a consumer debtor whose “income” IS higher than the applicable median income amount, through some good lawyering, which is creative but perfectly legitimate, you may well be able to lower your “income” or increase the reporting of your expenses to bring your overall under the applicable median amount. If so, you qualify for Chapter 7.
5. Chapter 13 is Sometimes the Better Option
The purpose of the “means test” is to make people who have the “means” pay back some of their debts through a Chapter 13 case. In the relatively few times that a person does not qualify under Chapter 7 and so has to do a Chapter 13 case, in almost all cases, the amount that must be paid in the Chapter 13 case to the creditors is much less than the total debt, making it not such a bad deal. Also, often a person who “just wants to file Chapter 7 and get it over with” learns that Chapter 13 comes with surprising advantages, which are more helpful to the debtor in the long run.
Posted by Kevin on December 27, 2014 under Bankruptcy Blog |
It’s human nature to hold off filing bankruptcy until after the holidays. Here’s what you need to know once you think again about filing.
The Quietest Time of the Year
For most bankruptcy attorneys December is the quietest time of the year. Because:
- people understandably want to focus on family and friends, instead of on their financial troubles;
- the materialism of the season discourages people from taking a realistic view of their finances;
- many mortgage companies ease off on foreclosures, and other creditors and collection agencies back off their collections, during this season, to avoid looking like Scrooges;
- people don’t have time to see an attorney—especially about bankruptcy–with everything they have to get done for the holidays; and
- no one has the emotional space to go talk with an attorney about messy personal finances during this already emotionally taxing time of the year.
Things to Keep in Mind Starting December 26
After getting through the holidays, and with the time for New Year’s resolutions approaching, one of your likely resolutions is to defeat your debts once and for all. If you are considering bankruptcy as one possible way to meet that resolution, be aware of the following after-Christmas, turn-of-the-year issues:
- Some debts ( cash advances on your credit card or purchase of luxury items) you rang up during the few months before filing bankruptcy—to buy holiday gifts or pay for holiday expenses, for example–might not be discharged (legally erased). That depends on some nitty-gritty details of your use of credit, as well as your intentions at the time.
- If you are going to owe income taxes for the 2014 tax year and expect to be filing your bankruptcy case soon after the turn of the year, that 2014 tax debt presents both some challenges and opportunities. Oddly, sometimes that debt can be paid in effect without costing you anything.
- A holiday bonus from your employer or a cash gift from a well-meaning relative can increase your “income” for purposes of the “means test,” either making qualifying for Chapter 7 more difficult or potentially turning your 3-year Chapter 13 case into a 5-year one. These major financial disadvantages can often be avoided through smart timing.
If you understand how bankruptcy works, these potentially troublesome issues can be turned to your advantage. The next blogs will show you how.
Posted by Kevin on October 24, 2013 under Bankruptcy Blog |
The amount of your income alone may not disqualify you from Chapter 7.
The last blog said that:
• You can avoid the “means test” altogether if more than half of your debts are business debts—they were NOT incurred “primarily for a personal, family, or household purpose.”
• When comparing your “income” for the “means test” against the applicable “median family income,” your “income” is based on virtually all the money you receive during the previous six-full-calendar-month period. Which six months make up that period depends when you file, meaning that you may have some control over your “income” and whether or not is it above the “median family income” amount.
• But even if your “income” is indeed higher than your applicable “median family income,” that’s just the beginning of the “means test.”
So here are the remaining steps of the “means test,” each step giving you another opportunity to pass it and qualify for Chapter 7. Be forewarned: these additional steps are not the easiest to understand:
• You can deduct certain living expenses from your monthly “income” to see if your “monthly disposable income” is low enough. Unfortunately, the rules for determining what expenses you may deduct and how much for each are almost unbelievably complicated. It would take pages and pages to explain. For just a taste of this, the allowed amounts for some types of expenses are based on what you actually spend, some are based on tables of local standards amounts, others on national standards. For our present purposes, what counts is that after applying those rules, if the amount left over—the “monthly disposable income”—is no more than $117, then you can still file Chapter 7.
• If your “monthly disposable income” after deducting expenses is between $117 and $195, then the following formula is applied. Multiply your “monthly disposable income” by 60. Then compare that amount to the total amount of your regular (non-priority) unsecured debts. If the multiplied amount is not enough to pay at least 25% of those debts, then you can file Chapter 7.
• If after applying the above formula you CAN pay at least 25% of those debts, OR if after deducting your allowed living expenses the resulting “monthly disposable income” is more than $195, then you can still file under Chapter 7 by showing “special circumstances.” Examples of appropriate “special circumstances” in the Bankruptcy Code are “a serious medical condition or a call or order to active duty in the Armed Forces.” So, be forewarned. Special circumstances is very limited in scope.
The previous blog showed that even the relatively simple first step of the “means test”—comparing your “income” to the “median family income”—has its unexpected twists and turns. Today we’ve seen that if your “income” is indeed too high for that first step, there are other steps to the “means test” which—although admittedly complex—which may get you successfully through Chapter 7.
On a practical level, the amendments to the Bankruptcy Code make filing bankruptcy more expensive for the debtor. Not only are there additional monies required for filing fees, courses and due diligence, there is substantial additional attorney time associated with filing even Chapter 7. Completing the means test and justifying the result to a trust is one of those areas.
Posted by Kevin on October 19, 2013 under Bankruptcy Blog |
If you don’t qualify for either Chapter 7 or 13, do you have to do a very expensive Chapter 11 reorganization?
Chapter 11 is dreadfully expensive. That’s part of the reason why consumers seldom file them compared to Chapter 7 and 13. The court filing fee alone is $1,233 . The attorney fees can be tens of thousands of dollars. Why so expensive? Because Chapter 11 was designed for large corporate reorganizations, and, in spite of efforts to streamline it for smaller businesses and for individuals, it’s a cumbersome, attorney-intensive procedure. So it is usually sensible to avoid Chapter 11 if either Chapter 7 or 13 will serve your needs.
But what if you’re disqualified from those other two? If you really ARE disqualified, then you may have to file under Chapter 11. But you may not be disqualified even if at first you think you are. So let’s look more closely at the qualification rules, especially as they apply to situations where at first it may look like you don’t qualify. Today we’ll give a broad overview about this as to both Chapter 7 and 13, and then in the next two blogs we’ll look more closely at each one.
Chapter 7 and the “Means Test”
The point of the quite complicated means test is to make people pay a meaningful amount of their debts if they have the “means” to do so. So those who do not pass the means test cannot file a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy,” or they can be forced out if. Instead they would usually have to proceed through Chapter 13, and be required to pay what they could afford to pay to their creditors over the following five years.
But the means test is often misunderstood. That’s not surprising given its multiple steps and odd combination of rigid formulas and discretionary enforcement. The following may help you understand it and potentially get around it:
- The means test may not even apply to you. It only applies to individuals with “primarily consumer debts,” meaning that you skip the means test altogether if half or more of your debts were incurred for business purposes instead of “primarily for a personal, family, or household purpose.”
- There’s a fixation on the first step of the means test—whether your income is above or below the “median family income” amount for your state and household size. Indeed a large majority of people who file Chapter 7 DO have lower income than the applicable median income. So they can skip the rest of the means test.
- The means test uses an odd and very specific definition of your income, one which focuses on the six-full-calendar-month prior to whatever date your Chapter 7 case is filed. This means that for many people their “income” shifts with each passing month, depending on the changes to their income of the past 6 or so months. So some careful tactical planning may enable you to fit under the median income amount by filing at the right time.
- Even if your income, as appropriately defined, is in fact over the applicable median income, that’s just the beginning of the analysis. There are a number of other steps to the means test, each with potential ways to pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7. We’ll go through these additional steps in the next blog.
The Chapter 13 Debt Limits
At the time of filing a Chapter 13 case, your total unsecured debts must be less than $383,175, and your total secured debts must be less than $1,149,525.
As you can probably guess, there’s more to this than immediately meets the eye. For a start, the terms actually used by the statute for these limits are “noncontingent, liquidated secured debts” and “noncontingent, liquidated unsecured debts.”
Debtors with relatively high debt are often present or former business owners who signed personal guarantees for corporate debt. When are those guaranteed debts considered contingent and therefore would not count towards the debt limits, and when are they noncontingent so that they would count? And when is an unresolved claim against the debtor considered unliquidated so that they would not count towards the debt limits, and when are they liquidated so that they would count?
What these Chapter 13 debt limits really mean will be the topic two blogs from now.
Posted by on October 13, 2013 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Don’t get rushed into filing bankruptcy when the timing’s not right. Filing at the right time could save you thousands of dollars.
Timing Does Not Always Matter Much, But It CAN Be Huge
Many laws about bankruptcy are time-sensitive. And those time-sensitive laws involve the most important issues—what debts can be discharged (written off), what assets you can keep, how much you pay to certain creditors, and even whether you file a Chapter 7 case or a Chapter 13 one.
It is possible that the timing of your bankruptcy filing does not matter in your particular circumstances. But given how many of the laws are affected by timing, that’s not very likely. It’s wiser to give yourself some flexibility about when your case will be filed. If you wait until you’ve lost that flexibility—because you have to stop a creditor’s garnishment or foreclosure—you could lose out on some significant advantages.
Today’s blog post covers the first one of those potential timing advantages.
Being Able to Choose between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13
Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” and Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” are two very different methods of solving your debt problems. There are dozens and dozens of differences. You want to be able to choose between them based on what’s best for you, not because of some chance timing event.
To be able to file a Chapter 7 requires you to pass the “means test.” This test largely turns on your income. If you have too much income—more than the published median income for your family size and state—you can be disqualified from doing the get-a-fresh-start-in-four-months Chapter 7 option and be forced instead into the pay-all-you-can-afford-for-three-to-five-years Chapter 13 one.
The “Means Test” Income Calculation
What’s critical here is that income for purposes of the means test has a very special, timing-based definition. It is money that you received from virtually all sources—not just from employment or operating a business—during the six full calendar months before your case is filed, and then doubling it to come up with an annual income amount. For example, if your bankruptcy case is filed on September 30 of this year, what is considered income for this purpose is money from all sources you received precisely from March 1 through August 31 of this year. Note that if you waited to file just one day later, on October 1, then the period of pertinent income shifts a month later to April 1 through September 30.
So if you received an unusual chunk of money on March 15, that would be counted in the means test calculations if you filed anytime in September, but not if you filed anytime in October. If that chunk of money pushed you over your applicable median income amount, you may be forced to file a Chapter 13 case if your bankruptcy case is filed in September. But not if you filed in October because that particular chunk of money arrived in the month before the 6-month income period applicable if you waited to file until October.
Conclusion
Being able to delay filing your bankruptcy in this situation—here literally by one day from September 30 to October 1—allows you to pass the means test and therefore very likely not be forced to file a Chapter 13 case. Being in a Chapter 13 case when it doesn’t benefit you otherwise would cost you many thousands of dollars in “plan” payments made over the course of the required three to five years. Clearly, filing your case at the tactically most opportune time can be critical.
The sooner you meet with a competent attorney who can figure out these and similar kinds of considerations, the sooner you will become aware of them and the more likely problems like the one outlined here can be avoided.
Posted by Kevin on May 14, 2013 under Bankruptcy Blog |
If your family income is more than the “median family income,” you may still be able to file under Chapter 7.
The “median family income” within a particular state is the dollar amount at which half of the families in that state make less, and half make more than that amount. “Median family income” amounts are calculated for different size families within each state. This information, which originates from the U.S. Census, is available on a table downloadable at the U.S. Trustee’s website. Make sure you’re looking at the most recent table.
Let’s be clear: if your income is at or less than the “median family income” for your size family, in your state, then you are eligible to file under Chapter 7. (Other separate hurdles may need to be addressed but those go beyond today’s blog.)
It only gets complicated if your income is more than the applicable “median family income.” As stated in the very first sentence above, you still may be able to file a Chapter 7 case. Here what you need to know to help make sense of this:
A. Simply figuring out your own family income to find out if you are above or below the “median family income” is much harder than you’d think. It’s not last year’s gross taxable income, or anything commonsensical like that. It’s instead based on a much broader understanding of income—basically every dollar that comes to you from all sources, with some very limited exceptions. And it’s based only on the income received during the last 6 full calendar months before filing, and then converting that into an annual amount. And that’s the easy part!
B. If your family income is higher than the applicable “median family income,” then you still have a number of ways that you can file a Chapter 7 case:
1.Deduct your living expenses from your monthly income to see if your “monthly disposable income” is low enough. The problem is that figuring out what expenses are allowed to be deducted involves understanding a tremendously unclear and complicated set of rules. In any event, after your attorney applies those rules, if the amount left over—the “monthly disposable income”—is no more than $117, then it is low enough so that you can still file Chapter 7.
2. If after deducting your allowed living expenses, your “monthly disposable income” is more than $195, then you can’t file under Chapter 7, except by showing “special circumstances.”
3. And what happens if your “monthly disposable income” is between $117 and $195? That’s where the real fun begins. Multiply your specific “monthly disposable income” by 60. Compare that amount to the total amount of your regular (non-priority) unsecured debts. If the multiplied amount is not enough to pay at least 25% of those debts, then you can file Chapter 7.
So to go back to the question in the title of this blog, you can see that even if your income is higher than your state and family size’s “median family income,” you can still file Chapter 7 under a number of different financial conditions. You can also see that the law is convoluted. This is definitely an area where you need to get solid legal advice.
Posted by Kevin on August 8, 2011 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Many middle class families find themselves in economic distress when the kids go to college. Well, unfortunately, the bankruptcy code does not help those families. It basically says that if you have to choose between paying your creditors and Junior’s tuition, Junior is SOL.
Read more of this article »
Posted by Kevin on July 20, 2011 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Under the 2005 Code know as BAPCPA, a consumer debtor must pass the means test to qualify for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Chapter 7 allows a debtor to make no payments to unsecured creditors while keeping all exempt property.
What most consumers believe is that if you are under the median income for your area , you pass the means test, and you get to file under Chapter 7. Yes and no.
Read more of this article »
Posted by Kevin on July 16, 2011 under Bankruptcy Blog |
The 2005 Act, BAPCPA, requires that a debtor submit to a means test to determine eligibility for Chapter 7. The means test was based on an IRS test to determine what part of income a taxpayer can pay on back taxes.
The means test has a two part test for motor vehicles. The first is an ownership allowance. The second is an operations allowance. The ownership allowance gives the debtor a $496 deduction per vehicle per month no matter what you owe on it. If your monthly payment is $200- you get $496. If your monthly payment is $600- you get $496. But what happens if you have your vehicle paid off?
Read more of this article »
