Posted by Kevin on April 24, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog | 
A business Chapter 13 case does not have to be complicated. Here’s how it can work.
It’s true that if you own a business that usually means you have a more complicated financial picture than someone punching a time clock or getting a regular salary. So usually if does take more time for an attorney to determine whether and how bankruptcy could help you and your business. But saving a business in the right circumstances can be relatively straightforward and extremely effective.
A good way to demonstrate this is by walking through a realistic Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” case.
Mike’s Story
Mike, a single 32-year old, started a handyman business when he lost his job a little more than three years ago. A hard worker and self-starter, he’d been itching to run his own business. He had decent credit at the time, owing nothing except his modest mortgage that he had never been late on plus about $2,800 spread out on a number of credit cards. Mike had always lived in the same area along with most of his extended family, so he had tons of contacts, and had a great reputation as a responsible guy who could fix anything. So Mike decided to take the risk of starting his business in spite of having very little working capital. He had $8,500 of credit available on his credit cards if he got desperate.
His business started off slowly, partly because he didn’t have the cash to invest in advertising. But he was creative in setting up a website and using social media, and worked very hard building a customer base and a good business reputation. His income crept steadily upwards, but way too slowly. Over the course of the first year, Mike maxed out his credit cards to keep current on his mortgage, feed himself, and keeps the lights on. But he simply didn’t have enough money to pay any estimated quarterly income taxes to the IRS, falling behind $3,500 to them that year.
Then during the second year of his business, Mike managed to keep current on the increased payments on his credit card debts but couldn’t pay them down any. Plus he fell behind another $6,000 in income taxes. Then recently, towards the end of his third year of business, after again failing to pay any estimated quarterly income taxes and falling another $4,500 behind, the IRS required him to start making $400 monthly payments on his $14,000 debt, plus to pay his estimated quarterly payments going forward. As a result he started not being able to keep current on his credit card payments, leading to ratcheted-up interest rates, pushing him over the credit limits and into the vicious cycle of large extra fees piling up. And now he’s missed two payments on his mortgage, putting him $3,000 in arrears.
In spite of all these distractions Mike’s business now has reasonably steady income, which continues to increase, slowly but quite consistently. His accumulated debt problems ARE taking a toll on his ability to focus on growing his business. In spite of this he still very much likes his work and being his own boss, and realistically believes he can keep increasing his income, especially as the economy improves. He very much wants to keep his business going. But his creditors have him in an impossible situation.
The Chapter 13 Solution
If Mike met with an experienced business bankruptcy attorney, this is likely what the attorney would tell him that a Chapter 13 case would accomplish:
- Cancel the $400 monthly payments to the IRS, giving him 5 years to pay that debt, with no additional ongoing interest or penalties during that whole time.
- Pay the $3000 mortgage arrearages over the term of the plan.
- Stop all collection efforts by the credit card creditors and any collection agencies. They would only receive any money after Mike caught up on the house arrearages and paid off the income taxes, and then only to the extent that Mike’s budget would allow.
- Immediately protect all his business and personal assets—tools and equipment, his business truck and/or personal vehicle, receivables owed by customers for prior work, and his business and personal bank and/or credit union accounts.
- Enable Mike to concentrate on his business by greatly relieving his month-by-month financial burden, as well as save him a lot of money in the long run.
- At the end of his 3-to-5 year Chapter 13 case, Mike will be current on his mortgage, owe nothing to the IRS, and he would have paid as much as he could afford on the credit cards, with any remaining amount discharged (legally written off).
As a result the business that Mike loves and in which he has invested so much hope and effort would be thriving and providing him a decent livelihood.
Posted by Kevin on April 17, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
If your business needs bankruptcy relief, you have to start with basic questions about how your business was set up and its debt amount.
Sole Proprietorship
The most straightforward business bankruptcies tend to be those in which the business is a sole proprietorship. Your business is operated through you under your name or under an assumed business name (“doing business as” or “DBA”). So, for purposes of bankruptcy, if you operate a sole proprietorship, you file bankruptcy in your name and it will include your personal assets and liabilities and the assets and liabilities of the business.
Other Forms of Business
Basically, this includes corporations, partnerships and LLC’s (limited liability companies). In these cases, the business entity is the debtor. If the owner of the business is liable under guaranties, the owner might also need to file an individual bankruptcy.
Purpose of Bankruptcy
Once you have established what type of business entity is involved, the basic question is whether you want to utilize bankruptcy as a tool to continue in business or as a tool to liquidate and shut down the business.
The General Guidance
Beyond these initial points, here are some basic rules. They will help you be a bit more prepared when you come to meet with an attorney.
1. A corporation, or LLC, or partnership cannot file a Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts.” Only an “individual” can. So, if you operate a sole proprietorship, you and the business may be eligible for a Chapter 13 filing.
2. Chapter 13s are sometimes mislabeled “wage-earner plans,” but any source of “regular income” is allowed.” The requirement is simply “income sufficiently stable and regular to… make payments under a plan under Chapter 13.” So if your business income—combined with any other income—is even somewhat stable, you would likely qualify under this “regular income” requirement.
3. But you and your sole proprietorship CAN’T file a Chapter 13 case if your total unsecured debt is $394,725 or more, or if your total secured debt is $1,184,200 or more. (Note: these limits are adjusted for inflation every three years.) While these may seem like relatively high maximums, be aware that they include BOTH personal and business debts (since you are personally liable for all the debts of a sole proprietorship). Also, the amount of unsecured debt can include that portion of your mortgages and other secured debts in excess of the value of the collateral. So a $750,000 debt secured by real estate now worth $550,000 adds $200,000 to the unsecured debt total. In addition, if you want to file a Chapter 13 as an individual and you are the owner of a corporation, you may have to consider as your unsecured debts those debts of the corporation which you personally guaranteed.
4. If your debt totals are above one of the above debt limits, you can still file a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” case for the business, but that means, for all intents and purposes, the business will shut down. Chapter 7 tends to be a better option for cleaning up after a closed business, whatever its legal form.
5. A corporation or LLC does not receive a discharge in a Chapter 7.
6. If your debt totals are above one of the Chapter 13 debt limits and you are trying to save the business, one option is a Chapter 11 “business reorganization.” for the corporation, LLC, or partnership. The disadvantages of Chapter 11 are that it is a hugely more complicated than Chapter 13 which translates into substantially higher legal, filing and Trustee fees, and the financial reporting requirements are more onerous. Bankruptcy courts have tried to address these shortcomings with streamlined “small business” Chapter 11s, but they are still often prohibitively expensive.
7. If you do end up filing a personal Chapter 7 case when owing substantial business debt, you may have the advantage of being exempt from qualifying under the “means test” (a test based on your income and allowed expenses) if your business debts are more than half of your total debts.
If you are trying to save your financially struggling business, it is crucial to get competent business bankruptcy advice, and to do so just as soon as possible. You have no doubt been working extremely hard trying to keep your business alive. You will need a solid game plan for using the bankruptcy and other laws to your advantage.
Posted by Kevin on April 15, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Most small businesses do not have any reason to file bankruptcy after they fail. Instead it’s the individual owner or owners of the business who may well have to think about bankruptcy.
Business Corporation Is No Shield for Owners of Small Businesses
Why does a small business owner sets up his or her business as a corporation? One reason is a concept called limited liability. The corporation is legal entity that is separate from its owners. A corporate debt is just that- it is a debt of the entity and not its owners. In other words, the investor-owners of the business are not liable for those business debts. That’s the theory.
But in practice it doesn’t work that way, not with small businesses. Why? Because:
- Many new businesses cannot get any credit at all, and so have to be financed completely through the owner’s personal savings and credit. This credit tends to include credit cards, second mortgages on homes, vehicle loans, and personal loans from family members.
- For those businesses fortunate enough to receive financing in the name of the corporation, the creditors will very likely still require the major shareholder(s) to sign personal guarantees. This makes the shareholders personally obligated if the corporation fails to pay. Common examples of this are commercial leases of business premises, major equipment and vehicle leases or purchases, franchise agreements, and SBA loans.
As a result, when the business cannot pay its debts, the individual shareholder(s) are usually on the hook for all or most of the debts of the business. The business corporation’s limited liability is trumped by the shareholders’ contractual obligations on the debts.
Ever Worth Filing Bankruptcy for the Business Corporation?
By the time most small businesses close their doors, they have run themselves into the ground and do not have much remaining assets. And often, what little is left is mortgaged, with the assets tied up as collateral, leaving nothing for the corporation’s general creditors. This applies not just to purchases and leases of assets, but also to bank loans which require a blanket lien on all business assets, and commercial premises leases with broad landlord liens.
Without any assets with which to operate, the business dies. Without any assets for creditors to pursue in the business, the debts die with the business, except to the extent the shareholders are personally liable.
But sometimes the business does still have substantial assets when it closes its doors. Assuming the business is in the form of a corporation or partnership and so is eligible to file its own Chapter 7 bankruptcy, doing so may be worthwhile for three reasons:
- A bankruptcy would enable the owners to avoid the hassles of distributing the corporate assets by passing on that task to the bankruptcy trustee.
- There are risks for the owner of a failing business in distributing the final assets of the business, which can result in personal liability for the owner. Filing bankruptcy avoids that risk because the bankruptcy trustee takes care of that responsibility.
- In some situations, a debt owed by the business corporation is also owed by the business’ shareholder. So when that debt is paid through the trustee’s distribution of assets, that reduces or eliminates the shareholder’s obligation on it.
Most of the Time You’re Left Holding the Business’ Debts
Regardless whether your business can or can’t file bankruptcy, and whether or not it ends up doing so, you will likely have to bear the financial fallout personally. By their very nature bankruptcies arising out of closed businesses tend to be more complex than straight consumer bankruptcies. So be sure to find an attorney who is experienced in these kinds of cases.
Posted by Kevin on April 7, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Your Business as a Sole Proprietorship
Practically speaking, your business is operated as a sole proprietorship if you did not create a corporation, limited liability (LLC), partnership, or any other kind of formal legal entity when you set up that business. You own and operate your business by yourself for yourself, although the business may have a formal or informal “assumed business name” or “DBA” (“doing business as”).
There are various advantages and disadvantages of operating your business this way. For our immediate purposes what’s important is that you and your business are legally treated as a single economic entity. That’s different than if your business operated as a corporation which would legally own its own assets and owe its own debts, distinct from you and any other shareholder(s). This blog post, and the next few on this broad topic of business bankruptcies, assumes that you operate your business as a sole proprietorship.
Chapter 7
Chapter 7, “straight bankruptcy,” or “liquidating bankruptcy,” allows you to “discharge” (legally write off) your debts in return for liquidation—surrendering your assets to the bankruptcy trustee in order to be sold and the proceeds distributed to your creditors. In most Chapter 7 cases you receive a discharge of your debts even though none of your assets are surrendered and liquidated, because everything you own is protected–“exempt.”
But if you own an ongoing business—again, a sole proprietorship—which you intend to keep operating, Chapter 7 may be a risky option. You and your attorney would need to determine if all your business’ assets would be exempt under the laws applicable to your state. Certain crucial assets of your business—perhaps its accounts receivable, customer list, business name, or favorable premises lease—may not be exempt, and thus subject to being taken by the trustee. Proceed very carefully to avoid having your business effectively shut down in this way.
Chapter 13
The Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts” bankruptcy option is generally better designed than Chapter 7 for ongoing sole proprietorship businesses. It provides much better mechanisms for retaining your personal and business assets. Even business (and personal) assets that are not “exempt” can usually be protected through a Chapter 13 plan.
You and your business get immediate relief from your creditors, usually along with a significant reduction in the amount of debt to be repaid. So Chapter 13 helps both your immediate cash flow and the long-term prospects for the business. It is also an excellent way to deal with tax debts, often a major issue for struggling businesses. Overall, it allows you to continue operating your business while taking care of a streamlined set of debts.
Next…
In the next few blogs we will focus on some of the most important benefits of filing a business Chapter 13 case.
Posted by Kevin on April 3, 2017 under Bankruptcy Blog |
Same facts as previous blog.
- Without a bankruptcy, a couple would have to pay about $30,000 to the IRS for back taxes, plus about another $45,000 in medical bills and credit cards, a total of about $75,000.
- Under Chapter 13, this same couple would pay only about $18,000—36 months of $500 payments.
How Does Chapter 13 Work to Save So Much on Taxes and Other Debts?
- Tax debts that are old enough are grouped with the “general unsecured” debts—such as medical bills and credit cards. These are paid usually based on how much money there is left over after paying other more important debts. This means that often these older taxes are paid either nothing or only a few pennies on the dollar.
- The more recent “priority” taxes DO have to be paid in full in a Chapter 13 case, along with interest accrued until the filing of the case. However: 1) penalties—which can be a significant portion of the debt—are treated like “general unsecured” debts and thus paid little or nothing, and 2) usually interest or penalties stop when the Chapter 13 is filed.
- “Priority” taxes—those more recent ones that do have to be paid in full—are all paid before anything is paid to the “general unsecured” debts—the medical bills, credit cards, older income taxes and such. In many cases this means that having these “priority” taxes to pay simply reduces the amount of money which would otherwise have been paid to those “general unsecured” creditors. As a result, in these situations having tax debt does not increase the amount that would have to be paid in a Chapter 13 case, which is after all based on what the debtors can afford. In our example, the couple pays $500 per month because that is what their budget allows.
- The bankruptcy law that stops creditors from trying to collect their debts while a bankruptcy case is active—the “automatic stay”—is as effective stopping the IRS as any other creditor. The IRS can continue to do some very limited and sensible things like demand the filing of a tax return or conduct an audit, but it can’t use the aggressive collection tools that the law otherwise grants to it.
Deciding Between Chapter 7 and 13 for Income Taxes
If, unlike the example, all of the taxes were old enough to meet the conditions for discharging them under Chapter 7, there would be no need for a Chapter 13 case (but may require additional work in a Chapter 7). On the other hand if more “priority” tax debts had to be paid than in the example, the debtors would have to pay more into their Chapter 13 plan, either through larger monthly payments or for a longer period of time.
There are definitely situations where it is a close call choosing between Chapter 7 or Chapter 13. And sometimes preparing an offer in compromise with the IRS—either instead of or together with a bankruptcy filing—is the best route. To decide which of these is best for you, you need the advice of an experienced bankruptcy attorney to help you make an informed decision and then to execute on it.
